When it comes to preventing pregnancy, contraceptive effectiveness, how well a birth control method works in real-life use, not just in ideal lab conditions. Also known as method success rate, it’s not just about pills or patches—it’s about how consistently they’re used, how your body reacts, and what life throws at you. Many people assume all birth control is equally reliable, but that’s not true. A study from the CDC showed that over a year, about 9 out of 100 women using the pill perfectly still get pregnant—but if they miss a dose now and then, that number jumps to 90 out of 100. That’s a huge difference.
That’s why hormonal contraception, methods like the pill, patch, ring, or implant that release hormones to stop ovulation. Also known as hormonal birth control, it can be very effective—if used exactly as directed. But if your routine changes, if you forget, if you get sick, or if you’re on other meds, it can fail. On the other end, IUD, a small device placed in the uterus that can last for years and doesn’t need daily action. Also known as intrauterine device, it works whether you remember it or not. Less than 1 out of 100 women using an IUD get pregnant each year. Same with implants—they’re among the most reliable options out there because they remove human error from the equation.
condoms, a barrier method that also protects against STIs. Also known as latex or polyurethane condoms, it isn’t the most effective at preventing pregnancy if used alone—about 13 out of 100 people get pregnant yearly with typical use. But when combined with another method, like spermicide or a hormonal option, it becomes part of a powerful safety net. And unlike pills or IUDs, condoms are the only method that also cuts your risk of catching infections like chlamydia or gonorrhea.
What works for your friend might not work for you. Your lifestyle, your health, your budget, even your stress levels—all of it matters. Some people need something that requires zero daily effort. Others want to avoid hormones entirely. Some need protection from both pregnancy and disease. There’s no one-size-fits-all. The best method is the one you can stick with, consistently, without it becoming a burden.
Below, you’ll find real-world comparisons of birth control options, from long-term implants to natural methods, and what actually happens when people use them in messy, busy, real life. No theory. No marketing. Just what works, what doesn’t, and why.
HIV protease inhibitors can reduce the effectiveness of hormonal birth control, leading to unplanned pregnancies. Learn which methods are unsafe, which are safe, and what to do if you're on both.